Abstract
The Supreme Court invented federal constitutional parental rights in a series of decisions in the 1920s. Pierce v. Society of Sisters continues to be widely cited and celebrated. The practical outcome of the case, prohibiting states from requiring that children attend a public school for any period of time, seems to most unassailable, and the idea of constitutional protection of parental power has intuitive appeal for many. This Article dives into the historical record and finds the outcome not so obviously correct. It digs into the Court’s opinion and finds a complete lack of legal or other normative support for fabricating this federal constitutional right of parents. This doctrine should be regretted rather than celebrated. Also regrettable is the missed opportunity to develop a doctrine of children’s rights regarding state exertion of power over their education and other central aspects of their lives.
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
2025
Publication Information
100 Notre Dame Law Review 1569-1605 (2025)
Repository Citation
Dwyer, James G., "Pierce's Problems" (2025). Faculty Publications. 2470.
https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/facpubs/2470